Smith Productions LogoClick here to go to home page

Photo: Layering Video Example  
TWR Special Effects
by Richard Phillips
The Waiting Room is an independently produced, dramatic short subject motion picture, developed largely by the same Smith Productions people who manage your content creation needs. Created as a labor of love on a small budget, The Waiting Room explores a woman’s inner struggles as she faces a turning point in her life.

From the very beginning we knew that seamless special effects would be required to pull off The Waiting Room. As it turns out, a whopping one out of every four shots in the final film demanded an effect of some kind.

The most obvious special effects requirement involved the age old trick of seeing multiple on–screen copies of a single character. While most viewers will understand that all the Sarah Whites in the film are played with great depth by a single actress (Jill Adler), there are also other effect shots in the production that are less conspicuous.

The Clock Is Ticking...

The first effects shot in the film is a close up of a wall clock. In the face of this clock we see the reflection of three copies of Sarah walk into the waiting room. This was one of the more complex sequences in the film because not only did we have to overlap the three iterations of Sarah but we also had to contend with multiple reflections and the clock’s moving second–hand.

Photo: A reflection of the three iterations of Sarah as she enters "The Waiting Room."
cinematography by Steve Smith
compositing by Richard Paul Phillips
Jill Adler as Sarah White

For this effect to look realistic, obviously the clock’s second–hand must be made to move. However, because we are recording Sarah’s entrance three different times — once for each visible version of her personality — making certain the moving second–hand is in the correct position for each pass would have been nearly impossible.

The first “second–hand” solution that comes to mind? Physically remove the clock’s second-hand and replace it with a special effect. But here is where we run into trouble. You see, one of the challenges of working on a shoestring budget is that you must borrow rather than buy props. Our wall clock was on loan. As such snapping off that little red second–hand simply wasn’t an option. Instead I removed the clock’s battery and manually positioned the second–hand where it’d do the least amount of damage to the shot. With all the clock’s hands now in fixed positions we recorded the three passes of Sarah entering the waiting room.

Photo: Behind-the-scenes photo from the director's "command post."
photograph by Steve Smith
Jill Adler as Sarah White

In post–production our challenge is to merge the three versions of this shot into a seamless whole while at the same time preserving all the reflections and shadows from the original imagery. To achieve this goal, animated masks had to be hand drawn around each of the three versions of Sarah as she entered the room. Furthermore, the original second–hand had to be painted out and replaced with an artificially generated second–hand.

Article Highlights:

Shooting with a mini–DV camera presents unique challenges when it comes to special effects.
Creating realistic looking movement:
View using QuickTime
View using Windows Media
Multiple copies of a single person:
View using QuickTime
View using Windows Media
Watch The Waiting Room
The clip available on the right demonstrates the fundamental steps that took the originally photographed sequence to what the audience eventually saw. Note that this example clip doesn’t demonstrate the masking required to merge and overlap the three copies of Sarah as this technique is explained a bit later.

Photo: Example of moving second-hand [left-side image]Photo: Example of moving second-hand [center 'animated' image]Photo: Example of moving second-hand [right-side image]

I hope you’ll agree that the effect turned out reasonably well; right down to the little bounce of a real second–hand at the end of each movement.

Clock Special Effect...
click one of the below links to watch the :38 second long example video

QuickTime Version

Windows Media Version

Sarah3

While in the film’s planning stages we faced a question: what is the best way to believably create multiple copies of Sarah White in a single shot? The most obvious solution is a method called “green screen” (sometimes referred to as “chroma key”). This is a technique whereby a large green or blue flat surface is placed behind the talent while shooting. In post–production this solid color is electronically replaced with another image.

In theory the green screen solution would have served our purpose nicely. But in practice not so much. The difficulty is that we intended to shoot The Waiting Room using a Panasonic AG DVX 100A DV camcorder. Unquestionably this is an excellent piece of hardware but like all DV cameras it possesses a quirk that makes it less than ideal for recording green screen images. What is this quirk? The DV format requires that the video signal be digitally compressed as it is recorded and the video’s color component is compressed most of all. Because proper green screening depends heavily upon a pure color signal, attempting to use this technique on video shot using a DV camera usually leaves nasty looking jagged edges around the foreground images.

Photo: Three shot of the Sarahs on the red couch
cinematography by Steve Smith
compositing by Richard Paul Phillips
Jill Adler as Sarah White

The only other alternative, and also the option we chose to use, is to shoot without a green screen. Instead, during post–production, an animated mask was hand drawn around each of the overlapping on–screen characters. At thirty frames per second and hundreds of mask points per frame, you can easily imagine why building the film’s effects took several weeks to complete.

The clip available on the right illustrates the merging of multiple layers of imagery into a single composite image.

One small advantage of selecting this method is that because we avoided green screening, with all the extra location setup and lighting that it would entail, we were able to shoot the entire film in only two days.

Utilizing the Knowledge

These kinds of quality production techniques can and should be applied to any content creation project. At Smith Productions we’ll make certain that every penny you spend shows up in your final production. We believe that your project deserves the best possible support and we know you feel the same way. Give us a call and let us help you increase the impact of your next venture.
Compositing Multiple ‘Sarahs’ Special Effect...
click one of the below links to watch the :26 second long example video

QuickTime Version

Windows Media Version


Smith Productions, LLC

telephone:
(801) 467-3995

steve smith:
steve@smithproductions.net

rick phillips:
rpphillips@smithproductions.net

website:
www.smithproductions.net

Copyright © 2006 Smith Productions, LLC
All Rights Reserved
Miracle Max: Don't rush me sonny. You rush a miracle man, you get rotten miracles.
button: Home Pagebutton: About Smith Productionsbutton: Services Provided By Smith Productionsbutton: Contact Usbutton: Past Issues of SP NewsSP NewsView VideoView In PrintView U Turns & Double TakesView ChromatherapyView PlaceView People & FacesView Objects